Our Promise...

129 S Pendleton Ave - Stop 1     Pendleton,  IN  46064  US               (765) 778-4800  


How to Consign...

​​The Sister Exchange

Consignment Boutique 

The Sister Exchange Ladies Consignment © 2013  |  All Rights Reserved

We accept items according to SEASON, just like department stores.  NOTE: No items are accepted in January or July as we transition between seasons.

We will not accept any item that is dated, soiled by stains, deodorant, animal hairs and strong odors such perfume, smoke, mildew or moth-balls. Items can not be excessively wrinkled or have missing buttons, snags, broken zipper or flawed in any way. Remember, good looking clothing sells. 

PREPARING YOUR ITEMS:  In order for you to get the most money for your items, all clothing must be newer in style (within 3 years) and arrive freshly laundered, pressed or steamed and DELIVERED TO US ON HANGERS, never in boxes or bags. 

CONSIGNMENT MONEY ANYTIME!  Payment for items sold may be collected anytime during normal business hours.  We will display your items for at least 60 DAYS and you will receive 40% of the selling price after the item sells.  The Sister Exchange determines the selling price for all accepted items according to brand, quality, demand, and appearance.   

We promise to provide an inviting and clean environment, top-notch customer service, friendliness and assistance.  We understand that by choosing us as your partner in consignment, it is truly an honor and you deserve the very best! 

The popularity of consignment shopping continues to grow and consignment is a great way to earn extra money with very little hassle, simply by clearing out your closet. 

Our goal is to make the store classy and a delight to shop so you, the consignor, can receive full value on your items!  If you think we might be a good fit for you, stop by the counter and talk to us, or give us a call.  We’d be happy to have you join the sisterhood. 

May 25 - 29: DROP & GO FREEZE - No drop-offs without an appointment.
June 19: Last day accepting SUMMER items.​​
Welcome!  We are excited you want to become part of the sisterhood.   Here’s how it works:  
The Sister Exchange accepts ladies & young miss new or “like new”, designer label or top quality clothing, shoes, handbags, jewelry and accessories from sizes PETITE TO PLUS!  The DAYS WE ACCEPT ITEMS for consignment are on Wednesdays, Fridays & Saturdays. 


BRING & STAY - Make an appointment, bring in your items & stay in the store while we review them. Any items not accepted & your hangers are returned to you same day.  Please allow a minimum of 30 minutes. We ask that you make an appointment for your first visit. There is a 50 ITEM LIMIT per appointment.  You may make as many appointments as you like each season. Appointments fill up fast so be sure to call in advance.

DROP & GO - Bring in your items, sign & go. No appointment needed, no's that easy!  Any items not accepted will be donated; we do not have the storage space for later pick-ups. There is a 50 ITEM LIMIT per drop off. This option is available to established consignors only on Wed, Fri & Sat between 10-5.  Sorry, we are unable to return hangers with the Drop & Go option. NOTE: Sometimes it is necessary to stop taking Drop & Go's when we receive an influx of incoming items. Please call ahead to make sure we are accepting before bringing in your items.